To those who watch only the movie will only see what the director wants you to see and you will not be able to indulge in the fascinating writing of shakespeare. What are some differences and similarities between. Macbeth reunites kurzel with adam arkapaw, one of the most exciting cinematographers around animal kingdom 2010, top of the lake 20, true detective 2014 and kurzels brother, jed, as. Goold chose to tell the story with macbeth as a russian dictator cultivating a cult of personality in the 1940s. Ive only just caught up with patrick stewarts film, shot in 2010 by the company illuminations which had already produced the film of hamlet. All the mist, the moors, and the autumnal feel add to the atmosphere. Conclusion between the two versions of shakespeares macbeth. First of all it is set in a completely different time period most likely the late 1930s to the early 1940s, while the original storyline is during the late 1400s or during the early 1500s. Macbeth is the story of a fearless warrior and inspiring leader brought low by ambition and desire. Macbeth, in comparison to five film adaptations for a 21st century audience. Jan 16, 2018 i liked each, in its own way, but i think the later version has the edge. Conclusion between the two versions of shakespeares macbeth, many differences are shown, mainly in the.
Director justin kurzel seems so intent on showing just how brutal the battlefield is that all that blood and gore threaten to overwhelm the film at times which may explain how damaged and haunted macbeth becomes. Compare and contrast the 2 movie versions of macbeth. There are battle scenes, and almost all of the characters are in military uniform. A comparison of shakespeares macbeth and rupert goolds film adaptation 969 words 4 pages william shakespeares masterpiece, macbeth, is a tragedy brilliantly brought to the 21st century by rupert goold. Apr 20, 2015 macbeths greed for power and pursuit of his ambition turn out to become his own worst enemy. The great thing about shakespeare is that its supposed to be performed rather than read. Nothing would get in his way from fulfilling whatever he wants to do.
Oct 05, 2010 the movie, marking goolds cinematic debut, will be presented on pbs as part of the great performances series wednesday, october 6, at 9 p. The main diffrences in between the play and the movie is the portrayal and functions of the witches, the changes of the setting and some key scenes, and the diffrences of the functions of the main characters and also the minor. They hail macbeth as thane of glamis and cawdor, and. Coincidentally, macbeth begins with the stage directions, enter three witches. Similarities between macbeth and the film, a simple plan. I had intended to see justin kurzels 2015 adaptation but found it was unavailable, so i have substituted this 2010 bbcpbs great performances production featuring sir patrick.
Coincidentally, macbeth shows the murder of a king and alludes. This movie is entertaining to say the least and represents the characters in a much more modern and relateable way. Go expecting to see a gorgeous meditation on the world of macbeth, heavy on. Polanskis story was much more clear, it stuck to the time frame and main plot, but he also added in some great. In the united states, it aired on pbs great performances. Although shakespeares macbeth is a play set in 16th century scotland, rupert goold modernizes the play by changing the setting to a sovietstyled country and implementing modern elements into the characters and theme. Go expecting to see a gorgeous meditation on the world of macbeth, heavy on the sex and violence, and light on the content. Watch the full film of rupert goolds macbeth starring sir patrick stewart and kate fleetwood following a london west end run in december 2007, a soldout limited engagement at the brooklyn.
The polish director roman polanski, working with critic kenneth tynan, adapted macbeth in 1971, shooting on location in the british isles. Macbeth is epic, cinematic, and gory, with scenes that are stunning to the eye and hard on the stomach. Feb 18, 2014 in the 1978 version of macbeth i liked that it was easy to follow along with because there wasnt much going on in the play other than talking. Goold 2010, and justin kurzel 2015 depict very different versions of lady macbeth. Sep 29, 2015 macbeth reunites kurzel with adam arkapaw, one of the most exciting cinematographers around animal kingdom 2010, top of the lake 20, true detective 2014 and kurzels brother, jed, as. How different is the macbeth movie 2015 compared to the.
The play macbeth, by william shakespeare, which we read and the movie, by rupert goolds, which we watch has several diffrences but all put out the same message. Macbeth vs tempest a discussion on the contrast and comparison between two characters in macbeth and the tempest as the great william shakespeare once said, love all, trust a few, do wrong to none. Compare contrast assignment this video is used for educational purposes only. In the scene where macbeth is shown the apparitions, there were. Macbeth and the tempest comparison essay 853 words 4 pages. This playwright written over 400 years ago has been acted out on stage millions of times but just recently it has been turned into the form of a movie.
What are the differences between macbeth the play and. Great performances macbeth tv episode 2010 on imdb. While traveling to the kings camp, macbeth and another lord, banquo, encounter the witches. Its primarily a war story, set in what i judge to be about 1955. Sir patrick stewart stars in director rupert goolds visionary take on william shakespeares classic play, which shifts the action to a foreboding purgatory in order to explore mankinds eternal. That same darkness also got very boring to watch and i dont think the movie had the same effect as the 2010 version. Both were filmed in britainin fact, bamburgh castle was a location for both, according to wikipedia. The story revolves around, macbeth, who struggles with his crazy drive and uncontrolled ambition, causes him to loose all of his family and friends, and eventually killed him. Macbeths greed for power and pursuit of his ambition turn out to become his own worst enemy.
William shakespeare s macbeth has been screened numerous times, featuring many of the biggest names from stage, film, and television. A thrilling interpretation of the dramatic realities of the times and a reimagining of what. Differences between macbeth book and movie answers. In the end, it is obvious that the macbeth from the play clearly has more ambition than the macbeth from the movie. Watching a movie passively, one can become lost in it. He sticks to the dialogue straight from shakespeare, though he cuts a few lines here and there and. Perhaps the most striking features of his version is the. Having watched and enjoyed roman polanskis 1971 version of this classic shakespeare tragedy, i was eager to schedule viewings of additional interpretations. In comparison to shakespeares portrayal of power, the original play is far more powerful in conveying its message. Compare and contrast the 2 movie versions of macbeth english 12. In 1998, a film was made from sam raimi based on a book of the same name, called a.
The first series of the black adder tv, uk, 1983, written by richard curtis and rowan atkinson, is a parody of shakespeares plays, particularly macbeth, richard iii and henry v. The similarities and differences between macbeth the movie. After the murder of duncan in the 2010 film, lady macbeth is. Oct 05, 2010 watch the full film of rupert goolds macbeth starring sir patrick stewart and kate fleetwood following a london west end run in december 2007, a soldout limited engagement at the brooklyn.
In the 1978 version of macbeth i liked that it was easy to follow along with because there wasnt much going on in the play other than talking. How do the witches appear at the beginning of the movie. Macbeths fruitless crown makes his fear in banquo run deep. William shakespeares masterpiece, macbeth, is a tragedy brilliantly brought to the 21st century by rupert goold. Sir patrick stewart stars in a gripping tonynominated production. In the movie, macbeth was very skeptical, and unsure about what he wanted to do. There are many similarities and differences between the macbeth the play and macbeth the movie. In the movie, macbeth was dreaming and in the dream banquo and. Director rupert goold has given us a very unusual macbeth. Macbeth nyt critics pick off broadway, shakespeare closing date. In my opinion, roman polanski did a much better job of telling macbeths tragic tale than rupert goold did.
Which macbeth movie is better, the 1971 or the 2015 version. We watched this version of macbeth for my senior english class because we just finished the story, and man oh man i think this movie is horrendous. To those who watch only the movie will only see what the director wants you to see and you will not be able to indulge in the fascinating writing of. Twelfth grade lesson is this a dagger which i see before. It was directed by rupert goold from his stage adaptation for the chichester festival theatre in 2007. Macbeth 2010 was shown on tv as part of the great performances series. Get an answer for what are some differences and similarities between shakespeares macbeth and great performances. In completing the film graphic organizer, one student notes that macbeth is in an empty room and that the camera is still. Film comparison student work 4 an additional example of student work shows more observations. Twelfth grade lesson is this a dagger which i see before me. The play features many interesting scenes, references to the unknown, and several interesting characters.
First of all it is set in a completely different time period most likely the late 1930s to the early 1940s, while the original storyline is during the. This is where we get guy fawkes, that guy in v for vendetta. Macbeth is a shakespearean tragedy that teaches readers about ambition and greed which resulted in tragedy. This movie called macbeth was produced in 2010 and was directed by rupert goold. Appearance is very different from during previous acts in the movie. Macbeth is a 2010 television film based on william shakespeares tragedy of the same name. Oct 01, 2015 despite macbeths brevity in comparison with shakespeares other works, this film is savage in its excisions, both narratively and aesthetically. March 22, 2008 brooklyn academy of music harvey theater, 651 fulton st. Macbeth is a 2010 television film based on william shakespeare s tragedy of the same name. The 1971 film shows the murder of duncan, and the 2010 film does not.
Comparison of mc beth the movie and the play essay 783 words. Movies and books are fundamentally different in the way they tell a story. This xrated film of the play features a nude sleepwalking scene by lady macbeth and plenty of onscreen violence. The movie, marking goolds cinematic debut, will be presented on pbs as part of the great performances series wednesday, october 6, at 9 p. Polanski also emphasizes the passage of time the events of play span several years, and the macbeths visibly age over the course of the movie. In the play, he would have so much drive to do complete his dreams. Macbeth is something i never read as a student, but now after reading the work and seeing the new film, i cannot understand how i managed to avoid it. Duncan announces that, as a reward for his valor, macbeth will receive cawdors title and property in addition to the territory he already rules, glamis. In my opinion, roman polanski did a much better job of telling macbeth s tragic tale than rupert goold did. Take rupert goolds 2010 version of macbeth, for example. With patrick stewart, kate fleetwood, oliver burch, suzanne burden. I happen to believe that the macbeth tale is quite spectacular, but whenever i watch a movie based on a book or an old shakespearean tale i watch it like im new to this world and its characters. Patrick stewart, betterknown to many as captain jeanluc picard on star. I chose to survey the women in macbeth specifically because of historical blame placed on either lady macbeth or the witches for macbeths actions.
Macbeth movie comparisons by siona wacheski conclusively. The story of macbeth, written by william shakespeare was a tragedy set in scotland in the 1600s. So the text itself is basically just dialogue and a few bits of stage direction including the ever awesome exit, pursued by a bear, which shows up in a winters tale. Because of its success, in 2010 they decided to film it, staying true to the stage production while still creating an engaging movie that was not just a film of a stage.
Roman polanski 1971, philip casson 1979, geoffrey wright 2006, rupert goold 2010, and justin kurzel 2015. In 1998, a film was made from sam raimi based on a book. It is a visual feast, and a warm up production for the same director and cast who will be doing the assassins creed movie. This lesson explores the 2010 film adaptation based on shakespeares macbeth directed by rupert goold, concentrating on how the characters of. Which macbeth movie is better, the 1971 or the 2015. A comparison of shakespeares macbeth and rupert goolds. Literary art of any form reflects its contextual surroundings despite the messages it is conveying. In the film, macbeths death is shown on the screen shakespeare couldnt have done this because king james wouldnt have liked a king being killed on stage. Additionally, the student notes the slow rate of speech and its effect. Shakespeare, in his original play macbeth lays the foundations that allowed geoffrey wright to build on in his adaption macbeth. I liked each, in its own way, but i think the later version has the edge. The movie macbeth, directed by polonski in 1971, is a good adaptation of the play because the settings are portrayed accurately. Patrick stewart is featured in the title role, with kate fleetwood as lady macbeth.
1087 1031 142 318 964 719 1367 123 540 151 730 1301 1136 578 1010 1342 765 441 167 787 1114 147 674 1391 197 417 1304 346 233 1379 248 244 834 54 1253 103